← Software
One ZFS for illumos and OpenZFS (long-term goal)
| title | One ZFS for illumos and OpenZFS (long-term goal) |
|---|
| recommendation | include |
|---|
| direction | both-differ |
|---|
| area | porting |
|---|
| feature flag | |
|---|
| openzfs version | |
|---|
| summary | Bring illumos ZFS and OpenZFS together so both communities share one code base: OpenZFS gains an illumos platform layer (module/os/illumos, as it has for Linux and FreeBSD), and illumos keeps what it does best (FMA diagnosis, SMF, zones delegation, kernel SMB/NFS sharing, boot environments, zfs_zone throttling) as platform code or upstreamed features. |
|---|
| impact | Solnix pools would import read-write on Linux and FreeBSD and back, illumos would stop trailing OpenZFS by years (today about OpenZFS 0.8 plus log_spacemap), and fixes found on either side reach both. |
|---|
| why | IPD 50 (predraft) keeps ZFS first-party with reviewed imports; the openzfs/openzfs illumos repo was archived in 2019 and OpenZFS has no illumos backend. A union has to be built in steps that each pay off on its own: (1) move the pin; (2) land the read-incompatible features that block interop (head_errlog, vdev_zaps_v2, bookmark_written, zstd), and the compatibility property with an illumos file upstream in OpenZFS; (3) upstream illumos-only fixes and features to OpenZFS (patch 0009 first); (4) prototype module/os/illumos against a Solnix gate branch, measured, and take it to illumos and OpenZFS as an IPD and an OpenZFS RFC together. |
|---|
| effort | large |
|---|
| sources | https://github.com/openzfs/zfs/tree/c913da86156eba3243cc1ef515e98d69887654a7/module/os https://github.com/illumos/ipd/blob/6c575ddfc1898caf7332dbad4429c1390f78ffb9/ipd/0050/README.adoc https://github.com/openzfs/openzfs |
|---|
What Solnix has done
- planned Maintainer's long-term goal (2026-11-17): align Solnix/illumos ZFS with OpenZFS as a union so both communities benefit. Steps 1 (pin) and 3 (upstream patch 0009) start now. (maintainer)
Objections (0)
None.
Sign in to object to this item.