Sign in

Software

Everything the OpenSolaris family has built since 2010, in one place: the distributions (living and static), the named features each one added, and how the ZFS in Solnix differs from OpenZFS. The community ranks what Solnix should take next, and can say why something should not be included. Every decision is recorded here.

Members of a solnix.io mailing list can rank items, object to one, or suggest one (sign in at the top right).

ZFS in Solnix vs OpenZFS

Solnix ships illumos-gate's ZFS. OpenZFS (Linux/FreeBSD) has moved on; this is where the two differ, what it means for your pools, and what we could bring across. 43 OpenZFS-only · 7 illumos-only · 16 both differ.

DifferenceAreaWhereOpenZFSRecommendationScoreObjections
feature@bookmark_written (com.delphix:bookmark_written) feature@bookmark_writtenfeature-flagopenzfs-only2.0.0include0 · 0v0
feature@fast_dedup (com.klarasystems:fast_dedup) feature@fast_dedupfeature-flagopenzfs-only2.3.0include0 · 0v0
feature@head_errlog (com.delphix:head_errlog) feature@head_errlogfeature-flagopenzfs-only2.2.0include0 · 0v0
feature@livelist (com.delphix:livelist) feature@livelistfeature-flagopenzfs-only2.0.0include0 · 0v0
feature@vdev_zaps_v2 (com.klarasystems:vdev_zaps_v2) feature@vdev_zaps_v2feature-flagopenzfs-only2.2.0include0 · 0v0
feature@zstd_compress (org.freebsd:zstd_compress) feature@zstd_compressfeature-flagopenzfs-only2.0.0include0 · 0v0
zpool 'compatibility' property and feature-set filesadminopenzfs-only2.1.0include0 · 0v0
zstream(8) vs zstreamdump(8)toolingopenzfs-only2.0.0include0 · 0v0
Corrective (healing) zfs receive -csend-recvopenzfs-only2.2.0consider0 · 0v0
Dataset properties OpenZFS has and illumos lacksadminopenzfs-only2.2.0consider0 · 0v0
Direct I/O (O_DIRECT, direct= property)performanceopenzfs-only2.3.0consider0 · 0v0
JSON output (-j) for zpool and zfstoolingopenzfs-only2.3.0consider0 · 0v0
Slow-disk diagnosis and RAID-Z sit-outreliabilityopenzfs-only2.3.0consider0 · 0v0
Vdev properties (zpool get/set on vdevs) feature@vdev_zaps_v2adminopenzfs-only2.2.0consider0 · 0v0
ZIL rework and embedded slogperformanceopenzfs-only2.1.0consider0 · 0v0
feature@blake3 (org.openzfs:blake3) feature@blake3feature-flagopenzfs-only2.2.0consider0 · 0v0
feature@block_cloning (com.fudosecurity:block_cloning) feature@block_cloningfeature-flagopenzfs-only2.2.0consider0 · 0v0
feature@block_cloning_endian (com.truenas:block_cloning_endian) feature@block_cloning_endianfeature-flagopenzfs-only2.4.0consider0 · 0v0
feature@device_rebuild (org.openzfs:device_rebuild) feature@device_rebuildfeature-flagopenzfs-only2.0.0consider0 · 0v0
feature@draid (org.openzfs:draid) feature@draidfeature-flagopenzfs-only2.1.0consider0 · 0v0
feature@large_microzap (com.klarasystems:large_microzap) feature@large_microzapfeature-flagopenzfs-only2.3.0consider0 · 0v0
feature@physical_rewrite (com.truenas:physical_rewrite) feature@physical_rewritefeature-flagopenzfs-only2.4.0consider0 · 0v0
feature@raidz_expansion (org.openzfs:raidz_expansion) feature@raidz_expansionfeature-flagopenzfs-only2.3.0consider0 · 0v0
feature@redacted_datasets (com.delphix:redacted_datasets) feature@redacted_datasetsfeature-flagopenzfs-only2.0.0consider0 · 0v0
feature@redaction_bookmarks (com.delphix:redaction_bookmarks) feature@redaction_bookmarksfeature-flagopenzfs-only2.0.0consider0 · 0v0
keylocation=https:// for encryption keysencryptionopenzfs-only2.2.0consider0 · 0v0
xattr=sa (system-attribute extended attributes)integrationopenzfs-onlyconsider0 · 0v0
zarcstat, zarcsummary, zilstat, dbufstat, zpool_influxdbtoolingopenzfs-onlyconsider0 · 0v0
zfs allow send:raw / send:encrypted / receive:appendadminopenzfs-onlyconsider0 · 0v0
zfs rewrite feature@physical_rewriteadminopenzfs-only2.4.0consider0 · 0v0
zfs send --redact, --saved, -U, -V, -Xsend-recvopenzfs-only2.0.0consider0 · 0v0
zpool scrub -e (scrub only blocks in the error log) feature@head_errlogreliabilityopenzfs-only2.2.0consider0 · 0v0
Is anyone porting OpenZFS itself to illumos?portingopenzfs-onlydefer0 · 0v0
Pool properties OpenZFS has and illumos lacksadminopenzfs-only2.2.0defer0 · 0v0
Scrub by txg or date range, scrub-from-last (-C, -S/-E)reliabilityopenzfs-only2.4.0defer0 · 0v0
feature@anyraid (com.klarasystems:anyraid) feature@anyraidfeature-flagopenzfs-onlydefer0 · 0v0
feature@draid_failure_domains (com.seagate:draid_failure_domains) feature@draid_failure_domainsfeature-flagopenzfs-onlydefer0 · 0v0
feature@dynamic_gang_header (com.klarasystems:dynamic_gang_header) feature@dynamic_gang_headerfeature-flagopenzfs-only2.4.0defer0 · 0v0
feature@longname (org.zfsonlinux:longname) feature@longnamefeature-flagopenzfs-only2.3.0defer0 · 0v0
feature@redaction_list_spill (com.delphix:redaction_list_spill) feature@redaction_list_spillfeature-flagopenzfs-only2.3.0defer0 · 0v0
feature@zilsaxattr (org.openzfs:zilsaxattr) feature@zilsaxattrfeature-flagopenzfs-only2.2.0defer0 · 0v0
zpool events, ddtprune, prefetch, condense, versionadminopenzfs-only2.3.0defer0 · 0v0
zpool status -e (only unhealthy vdevs) and other status flagsadminopenzfs-only2.3.0defer0 · 0v0
Dataset delegation: zones vs jails vs Linux namespacesintegrationboth-differ2.2.0include0 · 0v0
How far illumos ZFS lags OpenZFSportingboth-differinclude0 · 0v0
Importing OpenZFS pools on Solnixfeature-flagboth-differinclude0 · 0v0
Native encryption: local MAC differs with project_quota feature@encryptionencryptionboth-differ0.8.0include0 · 0v0
One ZFS for illumos and OpenZFS (long-term goal)portingboth-differinclude0 · 0v0
Persistent L2ARCperformanceboth-differ2.0.0include0 · 0v0
Solnix observation: RW-mounting an illumos root pool from OpenZFS-on-Linux corrupted itreliabilityboth-differinclude0 · 0v0
TRIM / autotrim data-loss bugs (open)reliabilityboth-differinclude0 · 0v0
ZFS channel programs (zfs program)adminboth-differ0.8.0include0 · 0v0
illumos-gate ZFS fixes after the Solnix pinportingboth-differinclude0 · 0v0
lseek(SEEK_DATA/SEEK_HOLE) ignores dirty mmap pagesreliabilityboth-differ2.2.0include0 · 0v0
zfs send stream feature masksend-recvboth-differ2.0.0include0 · 0v0
ARC eviction: adaptive and parallelperformanceboth-differ2.2.0consider0 · 0v0
Log spacemap feature@log_spacemapperformanceboth-differ2.0.0consider0 · 0v0
SIMD RAID-Z parity and checksums per architectureperformanceboth-differ0.7.0consider0 · 0v0
zpool wait / zfs waitadminboth-differ2.0.0consider0 · 0v0
Boot environments (beadm/libbe) and the illumos loader's feature listintegrationillumos-onlyinclude0 · 0v0
Device removal, pool checkpoint, initialize, TRIM feature@device_removalreliabilitysame0.8.0include0 · 0v0
FMA diagnosis (zfs-diagnosis, zfs-retire) vs ZEDintegrationillumos-onlyinclude0 · 0v0
IPD 50: illumos policy for consuming OpenZFSportingillumos-onlyinclude0 · 0v0
Sequential (sorted) scrub and resilverperformancesame0.8.0include0 · 0v0
Special and dedup allocation-class vdevs feature@allocation_classesperformancesame0.8.0include0 · 0v0
aclimplicit dataset propertyintegrationillumos-onlyinclude0 · 0v0
illumos-originated pool features (lz4, sha512, skein, edonr, multi_vdev_crash_dump, filesystem_limits) feature@lz4_compressfeature-flagsameinclude0 · 0v0
sharenfs/sharesmb via the illumos kernel NFS and SMB serversintegrationillumos-onlyinclude0 · 0v0
zfs_zone per-zone I/O throttling (illumos-joyent/OmniOS)integrationillumos-onlyconsider0 · 0v0
Code OpenZFS removed that illumos keeps (zfs remap, vdev cache)portingillumos-only2.0.0defer0 · 0v0